Skip to main content
NewQuran Gallery Chatbot is live!
Start Chat with AI
Logo
1 Subtopic
retribution in (also adopted by Muslims)

Explore Verses Related to retribution in (also adopted by Muslims)

At a Glance

According to search-discovered classical Islamic scholarship, the principle of Qisas (قصاص), or 'retribution in kind,' is a legal framework for justice concerning murder and bodily harm, famously articulated in the Quranic dictum 'a life for a life, an eye for an eye' (Quran 5:45). Classical jurists like Al-Qurtubi explain that Qisas is not a mandate for revenge but a legal right for the victim or their heirs, to be administered strictly by a legitimate state authority under rigorous conditions, such as proof of intent and equality between parties. The profound wisdom of this law, as Ibn Kathir elaborates on Quran 2:179, lies in its power as a deterrent, which ultimately saves lives by preventing crime. However, a crucial and universally emphasized aspect of this law is the divine encouragement to forgo retribution. The victim's party is given the superior options of either accepting Diyah (monetary compensation) or offering a complete pardon, which the Quran describes as an act of charity and an expiation for sins. This synthesis establishes Qisas as a system of perfect justice balanced by the highest virtue of mercy.

📖 Quranic Context

A foundational principle of Islamic criminal justice, balancing perfect justice with profound mercy.

Establishes a system of justice on Earth that deters crime, protects life, and provides a path for forgiveness and expiation.

References: The principle is most famously detailed in 5:45 and 2:178-179.

💭 Theological Perspective

Addresses the human need for justice and restitution while tempering it with divine encouragement towards forgiveness.

Provides a remedy for the anger of the victim's family by ensuring justice is served, thus preventing personal vengeance.

A legal framework that safeguards society, upholds the sanctity of life, and offers a concession and mercy from God.

Encourages the highest spiritual state by preferring forgiveness and charity (accepting compensation or pardoning) over retaliation.

📜 Hadith Perspective

The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) applied the principle of Qisas but consistently encouraged forgiveness and accepting Diyah.

  • Application of Qisas for specific injuries (e.g., a broken tooth).
  • A Muslim cannot be killed in retaliation for killing a disbeliever (in the context of historical legal frameworks).
  • The state/ruler is responsible for carrying out Qisas, not individuals.

Universal agreement among scholars on the legality of Qisas, the conditions required for its application, and the virtue of forgiveness.

💎 Deeper Insights

Search grounding reveals that the Quranic legislation of Qisas was a revolutionary reform of pre-Islamic tribal justice. Instead of a powerful tribe demanding a 'free man for a slave' or starting a multigenerational war, Islam individualized responsibility to the actual perpetrator and established equal justice, immediately curbing cycles of vengeance.

Ibn Kathir

A cross-verse synthesis of 'in Qisas there is life' (2:179) and 'whoever forgoes it...it will be for him an expiation' (5:45) reveals a dual-life principle. The state's application of Qisas secures the physical life of the community through deterrence, while the individual's choice of forgiveness secures their own spiritual life in the hereafter through expiation of sins. Justice protects the body of society, while mercy purifies the soul of the individual.

Ibn Kathir, Al-Qurtubi

Related Topics

Topics with Similar Verses (2)

Ask AI