Skip to main content
NewQuran Gallery Chatbot is live!
Start Chat with AI
Logo
helps his father David (ﷺ) reach a fairer judgment

Explore Verses Related to helps his father David (ﷺ) reach a fairer judgment

At a Glance

According to classical Islamic scholarship, the Quranic account of the judgment concerning the field (al-harth) damaged by sheep illustrates a pivotal moment of divinely inspired wisdom. The story, detailed in Surah Al-Anbiya, presents two prophetic judgments: one by David and a more nuanced one by his son, Solomon. Tafsir authorities like Ibn Kathir explain that David's initial ruling was to compensate the field's owner by giving him the sheep. However, as the Quran states, 'And We gave understanding of it (fafahhamnāhā) to Solomon' (21:79), who proposed a solution of restorative justice. Solomon's judgment involved the owner of the field taking the sheep to benefit from their produce (milk, wool) while the owner of the sheep repaired the damaged field. Once the field was restored, both properties were returned to their original owners. This narrative is not seen as a condemnation of David, as the Quran affirms 'to each [of them] We gave judgment and knowledge', but rather as a demonstration of a higher, divinely guided wisdom that prioritizes restoration over simple compensation, setting a profound legal and ethical precedent.

💎 Deeper Insights

The Arabic word for the special understanding given to Solomon, 'Fahhamnāhā' (فَفَهَّمْنَاهَا), is unique in the entire Quran. This linguistic singularity emphasizes that Solomon's insight was not just cleverness, but a direct, exceptional divine gift of profound comprehension, setting his judgment apart from standard human legal reasoning (ijtihad).

Al-Qurtubi, Linguistic Analysts

Solomon's verdict is a foundational example of 'Restorative Justice' in the Quran, a concept central to modern mediation and conflict resolution. While David's judgment was 'Compensatory' (giving the sheep for the crops), Solomon's was 'Restorative' because it aimed to return both parties to their original state, repairing the harm and restoring the balance without one party suffering a total loss.

Ibn Kathir, Contemporary Islamic Jurists

Ask AI