What is the ruling in Quran 58:12 about private consultation?

Quran 58:12 temporarily obligated believers to give charity (sadaqah) before having a private consultation (Najwa) with the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ. According to classical scholars like Ibn Kathir, this was a test of sincerity and a means to support the poor. This ruling was quickly abrogated by the next verse, 58:13. [1, 3]

Which Quran verse was only acted upon by Ali ibn Abi Talib?

Quran 58:12, the verse mandating charity before consulting the Prophet, is famously known as the verse that only Ali ibn Abi Talib (RA) acted upon. According to traditions cited by Al-Tabari and Ibn Kathir, he gave charity and consulted the Prophet before the ruling was abrogated shortly after. [2, 3]

What is an example of abrogation (Naskh) in the Quran?

The sequence of Quran 58:12-13 is a prime example of abrogation (Naskh). Verse 12 established a ruling (charity before consultation), and verse 13 lifted that ruling. Islamic jurists classify this as 'Naskh al-hukm dun al-tilawa'—the abrogation of the ruling, while the verse's text remains to be recited and learned from. [8, 9, 11]

Charity for Private Consultation (Najwa) in Islam

↑Parent: Prophet

charity during consultation with

Explore Verses Related to charity during consultation with

🕌Al-Mujadila58:12

At a Glance

According to search-discovered classical Islamic scholarship, the topic of 'Charity during consultation' refers to the temporary divine ruling in Quran 58:12 known as Sadaqat al-Munajat (Charity of Private Counsel). Ibn Kathir explains that this verse obligated believers to offer charity before seeking a private audience (Najwa) with the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ. This command served as a divine test of sincerity, discouraged trivial consultations that burdened the Prophet, and provided for the poor. [1, 6] Al-Qurtubi discusses the jurisprudential aspects, noting the universal consensus that this ruling was swiftly abrogated by the subsequent verse, 58:13, which stands as a testament to Allah's mercy. This sequence is a primary textbook example of Naskh (abrogation) in the Quran. It is famously reported by numerous classical sources that the only person to act upon this command before its abrogation was Ali ibn Abi Talib (RA), highlighting his unique merit and readiness to obey divine commands. [2, 3]

📖 Quranic Context

Highly significant as a primary and clear example of abrogation (Naskh) where the ruling is lifted but the verse's recitation remains.

Demonstrates a divine test of sincerity and generosity, followed by Allah's mercy and facilitation.

References: The specific ruling is mentioned in 58:12 and abrogated in 58:13.

💭 Theological Perspective

Serves as a test of believers' willingness to prioritize spending for the sake of Allah and honoring His Messenger over their own wealth and convenience.

Highlights the human tendency to seek proximity to leadership and the spiritual discipline required to ensure such access is sincere and beneficial.

A temporary ruling with lasting lessons on sincerity, charity, and the dynamics of divine legislation.

Illustrates the unique virtue of Ali ibn Abi Talib, who was the only companion to act upon the verse, showcasing his readiness to obey. [1, 2, 3]

📜 Hadith Perspective

The focus in Hadith is on the reports from Ali ibn Abi Talib (RA) detailing his implementation of the verse and its swift abrogation.

The exclusive merit of Ali (RA) in acting upon this verse.
The short duration the ruling was in effect, reported to be as little as an hour. [1]

Universal consensus among scholars that the ruling was abrogated by the subsequent verse (58:13) and that Ali (RA) was the only one to fulfill it. [8]

💎 Deeper Insights

Search grounding reveals this is a rare case of 'pre-emptive abrogation,' where the command was likely revealed with the divine knowledge of its imminent repeal. The primary purpose was not long-term legislation but the instantaneous manifestation of virtue in Ali (RA) and a lasting lesson on sincerity and divine mercy for the Ummah.

— Ibn Kathir, Al-Qurtubi

This event served to elevate the status of consulting the Prophet ﷺ. By momentarily placing a financial cost on it, the value of his time and guidance was underscored. The abrogation then made this now-elevated counsel mercifully accessible to all again, teaching reverence without creating a permanent barrier for the poor.

— Tafsir al-Maududi, General Tafsir synthesis

Explore Verses Related to charity during consultation with

At a Glance

📖 Quranic Context

💭 Theological Perspective

📜 Hadith Perspective

💎 Deeper Insights

Related Topics

Parent Topic

Related Topics (15)